Energy Encyclopedia

Compare

Compare energy sources

Qualitative comparison of major electricity sources. Numeric claims are omitted or flagged when they cannot be verified here.

Sources in the table

Counts among selected sources — not invented percentages

Qualitative comparison of selected electricity sources. Numeric cells are avoided or marked for verification.
FieldSolarWindHydroNuclear fissionGeothermalBiomassNatural gasCoal
RenewableYesYesYesNoYesYesNoNo
Fuel / resourceSunlightWindWater in the hydrological cycleUranium (sometimes MOX)Earth heatOrganic matterNatural gasCoal
Typically dispatchableNoNoYesYesYesYesYesYes
Direct CO2 from the energy conversionNone from the photovoltaic or CSP conversion stepNone from the conversion stepNone from the turbine; some reservoirs emit methane, especially in the tropicsNone from fission; lifecycle emissions are from the fuel cycle and constructionTypically low; some fields release dissolved gasesCombustion emits CO2; net climate effect depends on feedstock and land useSignificant; lower than unabated coal per unit electricity in typical plants, but not zero. Methane leaks matter.Highest among major thermal electricity fuels at the stack
Output patternFollows daylight and weatherVaries with wind resource; offshore often more consistent than many onshore sitesHigh when water is available; droughts reduce outputDesigned for high availability; refuelling outages for most LWRsHigh where the resource is well characterizedCan be dispatched if fuel is storedHigh; often used for flexibilityCan be high; less flexible than gas in many plants
Efficiency noteModule and plant efficiencies vary by technology; do not treat a single number as universalAerodynamic and electrical losses; Betz limit is an upper bound on rotor extraction, not plant efficiencyAmong the highest conversion efficiencies of any major electricity source when head and machine are well matchedThermal efficiency similar in order of magnitude to other steam plants; exact values are design-specificLimited by resource temperature (thermodynamics)Wide range by technology (heat-only vs CHP vs liquid fuels)Combined-cycle plants are among the more efficient fossil generators; simple-cycle less soSteam-cycle efficiencies vary; older plants are lower
Capacity factor noteClimate- and design-dependent; typically lower than thermal baseload plantsSite-dependentDepends on hydrology and whether the plant is peaking or baseloadOften high among large thermal plants; verify current regional statistics before quoting a numberNeeds verificationOften high for hydrothermal plantsCan be high if fuel is availableVaries from peaking to baseloadHistorically high where coal was baseload; now often displaced in some markets
Plant life noteModules often warrantied for about 25–30 years; treat as typical commercial practiceOn the order of a couple of decades for many turbines; verify project-specific dataCivil works can last many decadesMany plants licensed for 40 years with possible extensions; not universalNeeds verificationWells may need makeup drilling over decadesSimilar to other thermal plants if maintainedDecades with maintenanceDecades
Land-use noteUtility PV needs significant area per energy; rooftop uses existing structuresSpacing between turbines; land between can often remain in other useReservoirs can inundate large areas; run-of-river much less soCompact energy density at the plant site; mining is additionalRelatively compact for the energy deliveredCan be large if purpose-grown crops are usedCompact plants; upstream production has a larger footprintPlant plus mining and ash handling
Storage couplingOften paired with batteries or other flexible resourcesHelps firm variable output; not strictly required at low grid sharesReservoirs store energy; pumped storage is dedicated storageNot required for variability of the source itself; grid still needs balancingNot usually required for resource variabilityFuel itself is a chemical storeLinepack and gas storage support the fuel, not the electricityCoal piles store fuel
AdvantagesModular, no fuel combustion, rapid to deploy at many scalesNo fuel, scalable farms, strong resources in many regionsMature, flexible (with storage), long-livedLow-carbon firm power, high energy densityFirm renewable heat and power where geology allowsDispatchable, can use wastesFlexible, relatively rapid to build compared with nuclear, lower CO2 than coal at the stackDispatchable, established infrastructure in some regions
ChallengesNight-time gap, weather, materials and recyclingVariability, siting, wildlife, grid connectionGeography, ecology, sedimentation, social displacementCost, waste, accidents (rare but severe), public acceptanceExploration risk, location, induced seismicity for some EGSSustainability, air quality, energy densityFossil CO2, methane, price volatility, import dependence in some countriesClimate, air pollution, mining impacts, ash